Northern Colorado’s Best Real Estate Services

Decades of experience to get you the best result, buying or selling!

Fort Collins, CO 80524 1009 McHugh St

1009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 11009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 21009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 3
39 more
1009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 41009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 51009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 61009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 71009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 81009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 91009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 101009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 111009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 121009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 131009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 141009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 151009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 161009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 171009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 181009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 191009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 201009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 211009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 221009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 231009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 241009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 251009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 261009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 271009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 281009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 291009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 301009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 311009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 321009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 331009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 341009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 351009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 361009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 371009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 381009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 391009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 401009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 411009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 421009 McHugh St Fort Collins, CO - Image 43
Presented By: ;
  • MLS# 1055568
  • 04/03/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 8
  • Baths • 4
  • SQFT • 3,862

Home Details

Beautifully maintained, hard-to-find all-brick, low-maintenance 4-plex in a prime Fort Collins location behind Poudre Valley Hospital and just minutes to vibrant Old Town. Each unit offers 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, in-unit washer/dryer hookups and hot water heat. Interiors feature newer flooring and paint, plus some updated kitchens and baths that boost tenant appeal while keeping ongoing maintenance costs down. Strong rental history, long-term tenants and steady demand in this area make it easy to keep occupied and performing. There is no sign in the yard, this is a great opportunity to add a solid brick ( Low Maintenance) income property to your portfolio in one of Fort Collins' most desirable neighborhoods. Rents in the area for similar units are $1,600 to $1,700 a month.
Presented By: ;

Interior Features for 1009 McHugh St

Other Interior Features

LivingAreaSourceAssessor
BasementNone
Interior AmenitiesEat-in Kitchen, Washer/Dryer Hookup

General for 1009 McHugh St

AccessibilityLevel Lot
AppliancesNo Units Furnished, Gas Range, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Some Appliances, Disposal, Fire Alarm
Architectural StyleLegal Conforming
Association Fee IncludesTrash
AttributionContact9704300845
Cap Rate5.7
CityFort Collins
Community FeaturesPark
Construction MaterialsBrick
CountyLarimer
DisclosuresSeller's Property Disclosure
ElectricXCEL
Elementary SchoolRiffenburgh
ExclusionsTenants personal property
Expected Active Date 2026-04-03
Gross Income69720
HOANo
HeatingHot Water
High SchoolFt Collins
High School DistrictPoudre
Lease Amount FrequencyYear Lease
LevelsTwo
MLS AreaFort Collins
Middle/Junior High SchoolLesher
Net Operating Income53318.24
New ConstructionNo
Number Of Units Total4
Operating Expense16401.76
Parcel NumberR0000922
Possible UseMulti-Family
Property SubtypeMulti Family
Property TypeResidential Income
RoofComposition
Security FeaturesFire Alarm
SewerPublic Sewer
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Subdivision NameHighlander Heights
Tax Annual Amount6851
Tax Year2025
Tenant PaysDeposit, Electricity, Water
UtilitiesNatural Gas Available, Electricity Available
Virtual TourClick here
Year Built1961
ZoningRL

Exterior for 1009 McHugh St

Builder Model4 Plex
Irrigation Water Rights Y/NNo
Lot FeaturesLevel, House Faces North, City Limits, Paved, Curbs, Gutters, Sidewalks, Fire Hydrant within 500 Feet
Lot Size Acres0.24
Lot Size Area10283
Other Parking1 Space/Unit
Road Surface TypeAsphalt
Total Parking4
Water SourceCity
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

Elementary School Riffenburgh Elementary School
Middle School Lesher Middle School
High School Ft Collins High School

Nathan Washam

Broker/Owner
Price $925,000
MLS#1055568
List Date 04/03/2026
Property Type Income
Phone 970.988.8295
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 1009 McHugh St