Northern Colorado’s Best Real Estate Services

Decades of experience to get you the best result, buying or selling!

Fort Collins, CO 80525 4500 Stover St

4500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 14500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 24500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 3
42 more
4500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 44500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 54500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 64500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 74500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 84500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 94500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 104500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 114500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 124500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 134500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 144500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 154500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 164500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 174500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 184500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 194500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 204500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 214500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 224500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 234500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 244500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 254500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 264500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 274500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 284500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 294500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 304500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 314500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 324500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 334500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 344500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 354500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 364500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 374500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 384500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 394500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 404500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 414500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 424500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 434500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 444500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 454500 Stover St Fort Collins, CO - Image 46
Presented By: ;
  • MLS# 1050391
  • 01/26/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info

    Home Details

    Rare and exceptional investment opportunity in the heart of Fort Collins! This fully occupied, turnkey 4-plex offers reliable rental income in one of the city's most desirable and convenient locations. Situated on a quiet dead-end street with direct access to Landings Park and trails, this property combines walkable urban living with a peaceful neighborhood feel. Each of the four spacious 2-bedroom, 1-bath units has been remodeled and updated, featuring modern finishes and inviting living spaces that attract long-term tenants. The building has been well maintained with a newer boiler, fresh exterior paint, and a roof approximately 10 years old-ensuring low maintenance and dependable cash flow for years to come. Tenants enjoy ample on-site parking and easy access to major commuting routes as well as the popular Midtown corridor, offering shops, restaurants, breweries, and entertainment all within walking distance. Outdoor enthusiasts will love being minutes from Spring Creek Trail, Edora Park, and local open spaces, perfect for biking, walking, and connecting to the larger Fort Collins trail system. Whether you're a seasoned investor or looking to expand your portfolio, this turnkey multi-family property is a rare find in a thriving rental market. Strong rental history, desirable location, and solid updates make this an incredible opportunity in Fort Collins!
    Presented By: ;

    Interior Features for 4500 Stover St

    Bedrooms

    Total Bedrooms8

    Bathrooms

    Total Baths4

    Other Interior Features

    LivingAreaSourceAssessor
    BasementNone
    Interior AmenitiesEat-in Kitchen, Outside Entry

    General for 4500 Stover St

    AppliancesElectric Range, Refrigerator
    AttributionContact3037485023
    Cap Rate4.42
    CityFort Collins
    Community FeaturesExtra Storage, Community Laundry
    Construction MaterialsFrame
    CountyLarimer
    DisclosuresSeller's Property Disclosure, Lead Paint
    ElectricCity of FTC
    Elementary SchoolKruse
    ExclusionsClothes Washer and Dryer, all Window AC Units, all Gas Grills and Planters
    Expected Active Date 2026-01-28
    Gross Income65285.09
    HOANo
    HeatingHot Water, Baseboard
    High SchoolFt Collins
    High School DistrictPoudre
    Lease Amount FrequencyYear Lease
    LevelsTwo
    MLS AreaFort Collins
    Middle/Junior High SchoolBoltz
    Net Operating Income43930.09
    New ConstructionNo
    Number Of Units Total4
    Operating Expense21355
    Parcel NumberR0230332
    Patio/Porch FeaturesPatio
    Possible UseMulti-Family
    Property SubtypeMulti Family
    Property TypeResidential Income
    RoofComposition
    SewerPublic Sewer
    Standard StatusActive
    StatusActive
    Subdivision NamePitner Estates
    Tax Annual Amount6132
    Tax Year2025
    Tenant PaysElectricity, Trash Collection
    UtilitiesNatural Gas Available, Electricity Available, Cable Available, Master Meter-Electric, Master Meter-Gas, Separate Meter Electricity, Satellite Avail, High Speed Avail
    Virtual TourClick here
    Year Built1972
    ZoningHC

    Exterior for 4500 Stover St

    Exterior AmenitiesBalcony
    Irrigation Water Rights Y/NNo
    Lot FeaturesCul-De-Sac
    Lot Size Acres0.31
    Lot Size Area13670
    Other Parking2 Spaces/Unit
    Road Frontage TypeCity Street
    Road Surface TypeAsphalt
    Total Parking11
    Water SourceCity
    Waterfront Y/NNo

    Additional Details

    Price History

    Schools

    High School Ft Collins High School
    Middle School Boltz Middle School
    Elementary School Kruse Elementary School

    Nathan Washam

    Broker/Owner
    Price $995,000
    MLS#1050391
    List Date 01/26/2026
    Property Type Income
    Phone 970.988.8295
    Request Tour
    Request Info
    Visit My Website

    Similar Properties to 4500 Stover St